Two for one

[Jordoser]

i was messing around with the same render for two sigs idead for a while so i did it lol

[Timmeh_PS3]

1st;
I don't really like this one. Too much purple IMO, and get rid of the splatter is his face. It looks kinda weird. Also, make the left side of the sig more.....how do ya call that? erhm, well just make more going on on the left side, it's kinda plain.... Lighting and depth could use some work too...

2nd;
Nice work on this one,I like it Nice bg and render, and the lines are pretty cool However, the lighting could use some work....

[blackmamba]

1 - it's pretty nice, although the left part of the signature is too... plain. There isn't much going on with it. Good blend with the background, though. But yeah, the render is on the right side while the left side is just plain dark. o.o"

2 - Pretty good, but too colorful, imo. (at least, the left side.) Render's too small, I think it would be better if it's bigger and if you moved it downwards a bit more. Could fix the lighting and the depth of the signature, but pretty good.

[kazetsukai]

I love v2... It's colorful... Eye-catching. Xd Great! I hate the part, though where you insterted that little character. It's weird.

[Chista]

I love V2, but I don't like the little character thingy like Kazertsukai said

Love the colour though

[Ghaskamin]

The second one is better, but I kind of like both. Maybe the purple colour on the first one could be better, but it's not too bad.

*Edit*
When looking at them a second time I think the first one actually looks better than the second one.
Hmmm... Sorry if I confuse you, but that's how I feel right now. Too much colours in v2.

[rozarazan]

i liked v1 more since i purple is one of my favorite colors

[zangetsuBankai]

lol well unlike most ppl i like the 1st siggie more than the 2nd
the 1st does have its faults but it does have a superior flow although its kinda monotone >.>

the 2nd
i know which tut u followed & i think it would have looked better had you not placed soo many vector circles or brushes w/e the case may be

[zink]

since i love simple works which do not involve too many color i say v1 is my choice...

i like the design on the back of the render on v2.... the tiny pic on v2, it kinda distracts me.. ....

i will not say if its good or not or very good/nice... since im a noob also, i judge according to my interest ....

[hyourinume]

they're really nice, i prefer v1 though :3