Shana Sig

icefire017 · 12:16 AM

Alright well i made this today but im at a mental block on how to blend the render.
Advice needed as well as constructive criticism. Maybe i shouldnt even blend at all?

3 Versions

1 regular

2 Some scan lines (which i made myself by the way)

3 Blurred the edges...

**Vergil the Fallen** · 07-31-2008

I like the first version better. Its good. No complaints. As long as the render's and bg's background match, there is no real need to blur the edges. Good job man. Been a while since i saw a good sig (last was Zb's). And skip the scan lines for ur future sigs, they are waste of time and does not effect ur sig at all.

**blackmamba** · 07-31-2008

I like the first version the most, too. Although I like the idea that the render matches the signature, I think that the signature would be better if the render didn't match the signature that much. I mean, the render is red, her skin tone is completely gone due to the red-ness... everything's red. o.o"

But aside from that, it's a good signature. Keep it up! ^^

tomber220 · 07-31-2008

dude thats awosme like the first version best XD

Pineappledishwasher · 07-31-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by blackmamba

I like the first version the most, too. Although I like the idea that the render matches the signature, I think that the signature would be better if the render didn't match the signature that much. I mean, the render is red, her skin tone is completely gone due to the red-ness... everything's red. o.o"

But aside from that, it's a good signature. Keep it up! ^^

I like the V1 dude, its awesome, keep this up, this is good, but I have to agree with bm about the matching of the signature, look at her sig for example, you cant make anything better then that in terms of blending and matching the background, its the perfect dose of blending and matching xD

icefire017 · 07-31-2008

Thanks guys V1 it is....any more comments?

rozarazan · 07-31-2008

they all great good job

i like them

Nell Tu · 08-01-2008

I say v1 it's the best.I like the colors you used in it.

grandLuffy · 08-01-2008

The first one is better than the others.Continue the good job!

Kokujin_Hibiki · 08-01-2008

yes i agree with grand luffy the first is better