SOTW #32 - Voting

[EinarRhys]

Signature of the Week 32 Voting
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Theme: Japanese Culture

Voting Ends On: Tuesday, September 29, 2009 AT 7:00 PM GMT -5

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

- Please take note that members with less than 50 posts cannot participate in the voting.
- You MUST state the reason why you are voting for a particular entry. Those votes without any explanation/reason at all won't be counted.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Entries:


jhkplaya888:


Second Cell:


Glory Fades XP:


hyourinume:

[Vergil the Fallen]

I think this one is a no-brainer Glory FadesXP. His sig is simple, a little risky, but he handled it well. Which also gives him the 'different' aspect, in regards to his sig. And the fact that he is back to his good sig making xD
Jhkplaya888's sig is very simple but more on the negative part. No effects, nothing.
Secondcell's sig is messy and lacks basic sig stuff like depth, flow etc.
Hyourinume's sig is too messy and also lacks basic sig qualities. And nil depth. The render looks part of the bg.

[Hisagi-Chan]

I agree and also vote for Glory, I think its the best, especially because it looks so simple. :3
But I have to say, that I dont really think that hyourinume's is thaaat bad :O just doesnt all fit together, the red and things on the left side are quite out of place ...
and especially because Im a girl I dislike jhkplaya888's even more >.<

[Sonya_89]

I also vote for Glory. Because it's nice,simple and the colors fit well.

[randyly]

ummmm.......OK 4 jhkplaya888: i do like colors he has choosen 4 it and for Glory Fades XP: as everyone hve said already it is good but nothing is really on it. he could add more stuff on it^^.4 hyourinume: i like the background but not sure bout the girl sorry.

so........
4 me i vote 4 Second Cell: sig just because i like the blending of the color green and the other effects he has put on it, and it is not so simple^^

[RazerRD]

Voting for Glory

Simple and flows well enough for something that bland. Could use a little more effects though. Overall though it works well. Not often a plain-style sig actually looks appealing.

jhkplaya888's seems to focus more on the render than anything else. While the minimal effects and colours match well, that's about all it has going for it. (Smaller sig might also be nicer)

Second Cell's is too messy and the renders don't really fit well together. Lack of flow, depth, lighting, etc, etc. In particular the woman doesn't stand out enough and seems to blur into the background. (Different stock might've been better)

hyourinume's seems too all over the place. Nice stock but it doesn't stand out enough and there are too many effects throughout the sig so there's almost no flow or clarity. Same with the lighting. (Making the person stand out to give a focal point and then allow the effects to flow around that would work better)

[Vergil the Fallen]

So here is the scorecard:

Jhkplaya888- 0
Second Cell- 1
Glory Fades XP- 4
Hyourinume- 0

[zink]

wooo im back and alive... i think i missed this awesome category... hmf.. ... anyway my vote goes to..... *drum beating*

hyourinume

regardless of the category description ill vote for glory but hyou depicts the sig more with the culture though the sig was a bit messy.. a lot of extra effect....and lacks in focus..

second.. i love the color cuz its my fave but then the subject was also a mess... sorry to say that but still i love the green there... ^_^

for jhk,,, it was clean but it doesnt have the culture atmosphere, its more of a echi and i think japanese is not more about echi....

[corruptDNA]

i vote for glory..

[blitz88]

Second cell, it's the most appealing to me.