SOTW #6 - Voting

blackmamba · **SOTW #6 - Voting -** Jan. 2nd, 2009, 06:06 AM

Signature of the Week 6 Voting
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Event: Signature of the Week 6

Theme: Avatar
- yes, the anime. o.o"

Description: Freestyle

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

- You must have at least 50 posts. If you vote even though you don't have 50 posts anyway, your vote will not be counted.
- Contestants are not allowed to vote for their respective signatures.
- As much as possible, please state the reason why you voted for a particular signature.
- NO DISCUSSIONS HERE. If you want to discuss, you can do it here.
- Voting will be until January 3 at 11:59PM, GMT-9. Even though the voting thread may still be open after that, votes that weren't posted on or before 11:59PM will NOT be counted.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Entries:

byakuya17:

fidosdeader:

Kwack:

Timmeh_PS3:

Pineappledishwasher · 06:24 AM

My vote goes for Timmeh_PS3 (not going in to details since I just woke up)

I would have voted for fidosdeader but he has used the same background on three of his sigs already.

mosub · Jan. 2nd, 2009, 06:22 AM

vote for Timmeh_PS3:

zink · Jan. 2nd, 2009, 08:56 AM

i go for timmeh, clean and in modern style, cool... i would have go for fido but the thing is he used the same environment....

tomber220 · Jan. 2nd, 2009, 11:14 AM

well ill vote for byakuya17

sharingan09 · Jan. 2nd, 2009, 11:21 AM

Timmehs is awesome, clean and i always love vectors xP I vote for him :]

byakuya17 · Jan. 2nd, 2009, 02:41 PM

il vote for fido..^^

**Mushiro** · 10:00 PM

I don't think I'm technically allowed to vote, but if I were I would vote for fidos

He seemed to get the shading right (Not too dark, not too light) The text is easily legible, it's also the only one that went with "The Last AirBender" rather than "Avatar". It was over all the most visually pleasing out of all of them. However all of them are cool sigs. I'm not what you would call a pro at judging this lol

blackmamba · Jan. 2nd, 2009, 09:52 PM

byakuya17: 1
fidosdeader: 2
Kwack: 0
Timmeh_PS3: 4

**Vergil the Fallen** · Jan. 2nd, 2009, 11:24 PM

I'll go with Fidos sig primarily because his sig suits the theme and Aang himself. It has a very good feel to it. But the only complaint is the render looks a bit stretched.
Byakuya's sig was nice but was lacking depth and good structure and flow.
Kwack's sig was too rough, no structure.
Timmeh's vector style was good but did not have the Avatar feel to it at all. Plus the colored layers behind the render seem out of place.