Naruto's 2nd Affinity

[shadowfang2]

i would have to agree that naruto's second nature chakra is earth

[Lighty]

Originally Posted by shadowfang2

i would have to agree that naruto's second nature chakra is earth

It does not fit with wind.
Im sure his second element is water.
---> he could create ice with it!
That may be the reason Kishi gave Haku that ability!

[Jojo Bizarre]

I am pretty sure it would be water because of his mother.

His mother was from a water village (whirlpool)

He has wind from is father.

[Sintaro]

Have we forgotten about light and dark chakra manipulation jutsu? His 9 tails is the light side after all, and in addition to that, for all we know, healing jutsu could just be light/dark manipulation as it seem likely from this page in the manga

Naruto 316 page 09 | One Manga

[derekmcdaniel]

Originally Posted by EinarRhys

However, Kakashi and Yamato said that you can combine various elements to create others such as like Earth+Water gives you wood.

I am almost 100% positive that the combination of 2 (or more) different types is what makes up a blood line limit. This doesn't mean that 1 person can't use more than 1 type, just not at the same time unless they have a blood line limit.

[PrimeraOye]

It seems we have a lot of people assuming water here, but even if he was water, there is no way he could make ice from it. The ice jutsu that Haku used was part of his Bloodline Limit, if not for that, he would've been a normal village kid.
Truth be told, wind chakra flows enough and has the potential to give Naruto speed and all the other stuff that comes with wind nature. Earth, on the other hand, will give him some strength backing.

[Jojo Bizarre]

I am not saying that he could make ice but since

sasuke got fire and lightning

the opposite of those 2 are wind and water

wind is suppose to be good against lightning but weak against fire.

Water is awesome against fire but weak against lightning.

it all makes sense.

[Sintaro]

Not to be nit picky but water isn't weak vs lightning, its weak vs earth

[Jojo Bizarre]

Water and earth complete each other, to make wood...

[Sintaro]

That has nothing to do with it at all, bare bone jutsu without bloodlines, water is just weak vs earth, I hope your not truly basing all the jutsu according to Yamato's special exception because hes wood. To me, I would figure that earth and water make mud

And of course, lets bring in the flow chart from the manga, Naruto 315 page 13 | One Manga